"We can trust our inner yearnings, the ones we may have stifled in times past. We can realize our hearts' pure desires if we seek guidance."
You know how they say the road to hell is paved with good intentions? I think it’s safe to say that every relationship I’ve ever had started with a good intention. Once, I even told a therapist about my most shameful hookup, and he simply replied, “It just sounds like the actions of a kind-hearted person.” How did I then hand over my $20 co-pay for that? It was never about the one-night-stand's feelings, but my own? You know—the shame I led the conversation with? Perhaps it was my fault for confiding in a man three times my age with those kinds of emotions. I thought his PhD in psychology would outweigh his gender and age.
And he wasn’t wrong. Not really. Yeah. At the time, that sexual encounter was charitable. It’s what I thought going into it and what I thought coming out of it. It’s even what I told my friends. That was something—something I held on to.
When exactly did my feet get planted on the road to hell?
Probably too young. In second grade, I wrote “housewife” on one of those little About Me worksheets under the question, What do you want to be when you grow up? As the only child of a single mother, my understanding of a housewife came from watching Married With Children unsupervised—no adult to say, This show is a little too mature for you. Peggy Bundy was a housewife who didn’t cook, clean, or even like or respect her husband. I could do that for the rest of my life. It seemed far more reasonable than my mother working full-time, going to school full-time, and peppering the few moments in between with standing in a food bank line.
Even then, I wanted a boyfriend. I wanted to be the first in my class to have one, despite being far too awkward—and poor—to afford that kind of attention for a few more years. It was work to craft and carve myself into shapes and personalities that boys found desirable. But even then, it wasn’t enough to keep them. More work was always required to be a woman men wanted to keep.
In hindsight, it’s a tragedy that every man who ever said he loved me never actually had the chance to love me. They only ever knew a version of me I made palatable enough for him. Of course you love this me—I made her just for you. Like a bespoke suit, she always fit. They never saw the messy tailoring or the scraps of cloth left behind. You know—those pesky, stupid little pieces of me they wouldn’t like anyway. The pieces they didn’t need. Didn’t want. Could be discarded.
And what can I even say now? That I’m reformed? Absolutely not. Perhaps I am, at present, at my worst: a necktie that can fit comfortably around any man’s neck. Even Windsor-knotted for the last decade, ready to pull loose and unrestricted at any moment—for a husband I cannot explain.
My twenty-year high school reunion is this year, and even if I were in the same state—or wanted to see any of those people again—I wouldn’t go. My husband would want to come too. I don’t want those two worlds to collide: my husband and the people who remember an eighteen-year-old me. I couldn’t bear him asking, “What? Are you ashamed of me?”
The answer isn’t a simple yes or no. I don’t know how to explain a man twice my age and twice my weight to a couple hundred people who are essentially strangers, whose last memory of me is a bright, happy, promising girl. But, it’s okay, though. I hadn’t wanted to go anyway. Anyone from high school I want to see, I still talk to. My marriage makes sense to the people around me—the ones who’ve been watching my journey down and find the outcome rational. And it's been easy for new people to take it at face value having never known any other version of me.
Before you feel too sorry for me, I should confess: this path is exactly where I want to be. For now. That’s why I’m furiously plotting, writing, organizing my thoughts in orbits around how to make this relationship last until he dies—whenever that is. It could be tomorrow. It could be twenty years from now. If I wanted out, I’d be gone. I know all the off-ramps. I’ve used them before. But sometimes the easiest, safest, most comfortable course is straight ahead—navigating by muscle memory alone.
There used to be a lingering thought of what might have been—what could have been—if earlier in my life I had worried more about simply being myself, and less about becoming what a man needed or wanted at any given time. Maybe there could have been someone I fit beside as-is, off the rack, without a single tuck, trim, or hem altered.
But that thought has been replaced with a quieter comfort: that after the funeral, after a respectable period of grieving, I might return to all the pieces I discarded in service of another’s whims and wishes. I could patch them together, become as complete an outfit as I can—holes worn in my socks from the miles I trekked—and be wanted just like that. As I was, as I am, and as I will be. A patchwork of my good and even my self-serving intentions.
